| GAME |
| Rank | Free Throws | Name | Date |
| 1. | 16 | Jodi Urich at Cornell | 1-12-93 |
| 2. | 15 | Missy Ward vs. Clarion State | 2-21-86 |
| | 15 | Tricia Pawling vs. Canisius | 12-5-95 |
| 4. | 14 | Hilary Waltman vs. La Salle | 2-27-96 |
| 5. | 13 | Missy Ward vs. Canisius | 1-16-89 |
| 6. | 12 | Sue Shay vs. Niagara | 12-11-89 |
| | 12 | Beth Gromlowicz vs. Buffalo | 2-11-92 |
| | 12 | Amy Rooks at Canisius | 1-2-93 |
| | 12 | Jodi Urich at Navy | 1-7-93 |
| | 12 | Hilary Waltman vs. Canisius | 12-3-96 |
| | 12 | Hilary Waltman at Temple | 2-22-97 |
| 12. | 11 | Sue Shay vs. Penn State | 12-10-88 |
| | 11 | Sue Shay at Massachusetts | 2-18-89 |
| | 11 | Sue Shay vs. George Washington | 1-11-90 |
| | 11 | Sue Shay vs. Buffalo | 2-11-92 |
| | 11 | Jodi Urich vs. Rutgers | 1-14-93 |
| | 11 | Hilary Waltman vs. Temple | 1-10-96 |
| | 11 | Hilary Waltman at Temple | 1-2-98 |
| | 11 | Trisha Raniewicz vs. Siena | 1-2-00 |
| | 11 | Trisha Raniewicz vs. Rhode Island | 1-20-00 |
